Ep. 377: When Someone’s Disappointment Feels Like Danger: How to Hold Your Holiday Boundaries

When someone is disappointed with you, does it feel like you’ve done something terribly wrong? Do you find yourself explaining, apologizing, or changing your mind just to make the discomfort go away?

In this week’s episode 377 of the Fragmented to Whole Podcast, I’m talking about one of the biggest reasons people struggle to set and maintain boundaries, especially during the holidays: the fear of someone else’s disappointment. I’ll share how I used to experience other people’s reactions as if my safety were threatened, why that fear is often rooted in a fear of disconnection, and how learning to stay connected to yourself can change everything.

Some of the talking points I go over in this episode include:

  • Why someone else’s disappointment can feel like danger, especially when you’ve learned to maintain relationships by accommodating others and abandoning your own needs.
  • How to distinguish discomfort from actual danger, and why feeling guilty, scared, or anxious after setting a boundary doesn’t necessarily mean you’ve done something wrong.
  • Practical ways to calm your nervous system when someone pushes back, including grounding techniques, gentle breathing, and reassuring self-talk.
  • What to say when someone challenges your holiday boundaries, and how to communicate your decisions without overexplaining, apologizing, or defending yourself.
  • Why giving in to someone’s disappointment may bring short-term relief but reinforce the pattern of abandoning yourself, and how tolerating discomfort helps build internal safety and self-trust.

The goal isn’t to find the perfect words that guarantee nobody will be upset with you. That’s not possible. The real work is learning that you can communicate respectfully, allow someone else to have their feelings, and still stand by a decision that works for you.

You don’t have to make someone else feel better in order to feel okay yourself. You can feel scared and still have your own back. You can let somebody be disappointed without abandoning yourself to maintain the connection.

As you move through the holidays, ask yourself: What’s happening inside of me because this person is upset? And what could I do to support myself without changing my decision?

Be sure to tune in to all the episodes to receive tons of practical tips on living a more whole life and to hear even more about the points outlined above.

Thank you for listening! If you enjoyed this episode, take a screenshot of the episode to post in your stories and tag me! And don’t forget to follow, rate and review the podcast and tell me your key takeaways!

Learn more about Fragmented to Whole at Fragmented to Whole Podcast

New to my work: START HERE

CONNECT WITH BARB NANGLE:

Subscribe to “Friday Fragments” weekly newsletter

Linkedin

Work with Barb! 

Book an Unshakable You Readiness Call

Read the transcrip

Today I want to talk about something that I think is one of the biggest reasons people struggle to set and maintain boundaries, especially during the holidays.

It’s what happens when someone doesn’t like your boundary.

Maybe they’re disappointed. Maybe they get angry. Maybe they try to talk you out of it. Or maybe they don’t say much of anything, but you can tell they’re unhappy.

For some people, that’s uncomfortable. For others, including the old me, it can feel like a life threatening situation.

And I don’t mean that metaphorically.

I mean that my whole internal system would react as if my life were actually in danger.

And here’s the thing. I didn’t even have to set the boundary for that to happen.

Just the thought of setting a boundary could send my entire nervous system into a panic.

I would imagine what the other person was going to say. I’d anticipate their disappointment or anger. I’d think about how terrible it was going to feel when they were upset with me.

And I could work myself into such a state that by the time I actually had an opportunity to set the boundary, I’d already talked myself out of it.

Does that sound familiar?

What I understand now, that I didn’t understand back then, is that all of that fear was about disconnection.

I was terrified of losing my connection with the other person.

But there’s another layer to this that I think is even more important.

I was already disconnecting from myself in order to maintain connection with them.

In other words, I was abandoning myself.

I had this deeply ingrained belief that the only way people were going to want to stay connected to me was if I did what they wanted.

If I accommodated them.

If I made things easier for them.

If I didn’t inconvenience them or disappoint them or make them uncomfortable.

Somewhere along the way, I’d learned that maintaining connection with other people required me to sacrifice my connection with myself.

And I didn’t even know I was doing it.

I thought I was just being a nice, considerate friend, a good family member, you know – a good person.

But what I was actually doing was organizing my behavior around other people’s comfort because I believed that was what kept me safe.

And the holidays can bring this pattern roaring to the surface.

Think about all the expectations that come with the holidays.

Where you’re going to spend them. How long you’re going to stay. Who you’re going to invite. Whether someone’s going to stay at your house. How much money you’re going to spend. What traditions you’re going to participate in. And the weight of those traditions can be ENORMOUS!

There are so many opportunities for someone to want something different from what you want.

And if you’re someone who learned that disappointing people threatens your connection with them, all those expectations can feel like landmines.

You might find yourself agreeing to things you don’t want to do before anybody even asks.

Or rehearsing conversations in your head, imagining how upset somebody’s going to be.

Or deciding that it’s just easier to go along with what everybody else wants.

But easier for whom?

And at what cost?

Now let’s say you’ve done some recovery work. You’ve started learning about boundaries. You’re beginning to recognize that you actually get to have preferences and needs and limits.

And you finally work up the courage to set a boundary.

Maybe you tell your family that you’re not hosting Thanksgiving this year.

Or that you’re going to stay in a hotel instead of sleeping at their house.

Or that you’re only coming for a few hours instead of spending the entire weekend.

And the other person gets disappointed.

Or they push back.

Or they say something like, “But we’ve always done it this way!”

And suddenly your whole internal system is on fire.

Because there it is.

Your worst fear coming true.

Someone’s unhappy with you.

And if you’re anything like I used to be, your immediate interpretation is that you’ve done something wrong.

You start thinking, “Oh my God, I shouldn’t have said that. I hurt their feelings. I’m being selfish. Maybe I’m making too big a deal out of this. Maybe I should just do what they want.”

And before you know it, you’re explaining yourself, apologizing, offering compromises you don’t really want to make, or reversing your decision altogether.

But here’s what I really want you to understand.

Your nervous system being on fire isn’t proof that you’ve done something wrong.

It may actually be a sign that you’re doing something very different from what you’ve done in the past.

You’re breaking an old pattern.

And your system doesn’t know yet that it’s safe to do that.

Think about it.

If you’ve spent decades accommodating other people in order to maintain connection, then making a decision that somebody doesn’t like is going to feel completely foreign.

Your system is accustomed to you managing other people’s feelings.

It’s accustomed to you putting their comfort ahead of your own.

It’s accustomed to you abandoning yourself.

So when you do something different, of course it’s going to feel uncomfortable.

Of course it’s going to feel scary.

But that doesn’t mean you’re in danger.

And it certainly doesn’t mean you need to change your decision.

This has been such an important part of my own recovery.

Learning to distinguish between discomfort and danger.

Because for much of my life, they felt like the same thing.

If somebody was upset with me, I felt threatened.

If somebody was disappointed in me, I felt like I was in trouble.

If somebody didn’t like a decision I’d made, I felt responsible for fixing it.

And I didn’t understand that I could experience all those feelings without doing anything about the other person’s reaction.

I could feel uncomfortable and still maintain my boundary.

I could feel scared and still stay connected to myself.

I could allow someone else to be disappointed without making their disappointment my responsibility.

Now, I want to be clear about something.

I’m not talking about situations where someone is actually threatening your safety. That’s a different situation, and protecting yourself may require a different response.

I’m talking about those situations where you’re physically safe, but your internal system is reacting as though you’re not.

And one of the things that’s helped me tremendously is learning to tell myself:

“Discomfort doesn’t mean danger.”

“I’m not in trouble.”

“I haven’t done anything wrong.”

“This is what it feels like to change an old pattern.”

I can remind myself that the discomfort is temporary, and that I don’t have to make a permanent decision based on a temporary feeling.

Because here’s what happens when we keep practicing.

Our system starts to learn that we can disappoint people and survive.

We can say no and survive.

We can have someone be unhappy with us and still be okay.

And eventually, those situations don’t have the same charge they used to.

Not because everybody suddenly starts liking our boundaries.

But because we’ve learned how to stay with ourselves when they don’t.

Now, I don’t want to just talk about this conceptually, because I know how difficult it can be when you’re actually in the middle of one of these situations.

So I want to share some things I do that have helped me tremendously.

The first thing is that I focus on calming my nervous system before I try to figure out what to say or do.

And I’ve learned that there are some very simple things that work really well for me.

One is putting my hand on my chest.

Another is taking some nice, deep, comfortable breaths so I can catch my breath.

I also use my senses to bring myself into the present moment.

But there’s one technique in particular that I find incredibly effective, and it’s so simple that I want to describe it to you.

I take my thumb and forefinger and rub them together very, very gently.

And when I say gently, I mean barely touching.

Then I pay such close attention to what I’m feeling that I can actually feel the ridges of my fingerprints on both my thumb and finger.

I’m focusing so intently on that tiny sensation that I can’t focus on anything else.

And after just a few seconds, I can literally feel my nervous system begin to relax.

I catch my breath.

I start feeling present again.

It’s remarkable to me how effective something so simple can be.

And the beauty of it is that I can do it just about anywhere.

I don’t need to leave the room. I don’t need any special equipment. Nobody even needs to know I’m doing it.

Once I’ve calmed down a little, that’s when I start talking to myself.

And I might say things like:

“You’re okay.”

“You’re not in trouble.”

“Discomfort doesn’t mean danger.”

“You haven’t done anything wrong.”

“You’re allowed to make decisions that work for you.”

And I might need to repeat those things several times.

Because remember, I’m not trying to talk myself out of having feelings.

I’m helping myself feel safe enough to have them.

That’s an important distinction.

The goal isn’t to stop feeling uncomfortable. The goal is to be able to tolerate the discomfort without abandoning myself.

Another thing that can be really helpful, especially during the holidays, is thinking ahead about what you might say if someone pushes back on your boundary.

And I don’t mean you need to prepare a whole speech.

In fact, the less you say sometimes, the better.

But having a few phrases ready can make a huge difference, particularly when your nervous system gets activated and it’s hard to think clearly.

For example, let’s say you’ve decided that instead of staying at a family member’s house, you’re going to stay in a hotel.

And they say, “Oh, come on! We have plenty of room! Why would you spend money on a hotel?”

You might say:

“I know you were looking forward to having us stay with you. We’ve already booked a hotel, and we’ll see you in the morning.”

That’s it.

You’re acknowledging their disappointment without making it your responsibility to eliminate it.

Or maybe someone wants you to come over for the entire day, and you’ve decided that three hours is what works for you.

You might say:

“I understand you’d prefer that we come for the whole day. We’re available from two until five.”

Notice that you’re not defending your decision.

You’re not explaining all the reasons why three hours is enough.

You’re simply communicating what you’ve decided.

And what if they keep pushing?

What if they keep asking why or trying to convince you to change your mind?

You can say:

“I’ve answered that, and I’m not going to keep discussing it.”

Now, I know that for some of you, just hearing that sentence might make your stomach tighten.

Because you’re imagining how somebody in your life would react if you said it.

And that’s exactly what we’re talking about today.

The work isn’t necessarily figuring out how to say something in a way that guarantees the other person won’t be upset. That’s actually not a thing!

The work is learning that you can say something respectful and clear, and the other person might still be upset.

And – you can handle that.

One other thing I want to mention is that you get to set yourself up for success.

For me, it’s often much easier to communicate something difficult by email or over the phone than it is to do it face to face.

Because I can have notes in front of me.

I can think through what I want to say ahead of time.

And if I’m emailing, I can take my time and make sure I’m communicating what I actually want to communicate instead of reacting in the moment.

There’s nothing wrong with choosing a method of communication that supports you in maintaining your boundaries.

You don’t get extra credit for doing it the hardest possible way.

There’s a shift I want to invite you to make, because I think it gets to the heart of this whole issue.

When someone doesn’t like a decision you’ve made, instead of focusing on what’s happening inside of them, start paying attention to what’s happening inside of you.

In other words, instead of asking:

“Why are they upset, and how do I fix it?”

Start asking:

“What’s happening inside of me because they’re upset?”

That’s a completely different question.

And it’s one that puts your attention back where it belongs.

On you.

Maybe you’re feeling scared or guilty or ashamed.

Maybe you’re having that old familiar feeling that you’ve done something wrong and you’re about to get in trouble.

Whatever it is, you get to notice it.

You get to acknowledge it, 

then help yourself through it.

You don’t have to make the other person feel better in order for you to feel better.

And I think that’s something a lot of us never learned.

We learned to regulate ourselves by regulating other people.

If they were happy, we could relax.

If they were calm, we could relax.

If they approved of us, we could relax.

So when somebody was upset, our instinct was to get them back to a place where we could feel okay.

And that often meant abandoning ourselves.

But what we’re learning in recovery is that we can create safety inside ourselves.

We don’t have to depend on other people’s reactions to determine whether we’re okay. And you can’t create internal safety by focusing externally.

Something else I want you to think about is what happens when you give in to someone’s disappointment.

Let’s say you’ve told your family you’re only coming for three hours.

They’re upset.

Your system goes on fire.

You feel guilty and anxious and uncomfortable.

And finally you say, “Okay, fine. We’ll come for the whole day.”

What happens?

You probably feel some immediate relief.

The other person is happy again.

The tension goes away.

You can breathe.

And that relief can be incredibly powerful.

But what have you actually accomplished?

You’ve reinforced the very pattern you’re trying to change.

You’ve taught yourself, once again, that the way to feel safe is to abandon yourself.

And you’ve missed an opportunity to learn that you can tolerate somebody else’s disappointment without doing anything to fix it.

Now, I’m not saying that to make anybody feel bad.

God knows I’ve done this more times than I can count.

I’m saying it because I want you to understand the difference between what works in the short term and what works in the long term.

In the short term, giving in might calm everybody down.

But in the long term, it keeps you trapped in the same pattern.

What we’re looking to do is change that pattern.

And that means there are going to be times when we have to tolerate some discomfort. Actually, like I say to my clients all the time, we GET TO learn to tolerate discomfort.

We GET to let somebody be disappointed.

We GET to let our nervous system settle without changing our decision.

And we GET to to trust that we can handle what comes next.

Because every time we do that, we’re building something incredibly valuable.

We’re building internal safety.

We’re building self trust.

We’re learning that we can have our own backs.

And we’re teaching ourselves that connection with other people doesn’t have to come at the expense of connection with ourselves.

That distinction between have to and get to is imperative. I think this is probably the most frequent thing I say to clients you get to you get to you get to. The difference between have to or must and get to the difference between should and could is so important because it’s an indication of the possibility of choice when you have to do something when you must do something when you should do something it feels like you’re being compelled by some outside force but when you switch your language to I get to or I could you are acknowledging I have choices. Acknowledging that you choices is one of the most empowering things you can do for yourself

I think one of the biggest misconceptions about boundaries is that the hardest part is figuring out what to say.

And don’t get me wrong. That can be difficult, especially when you’re just starting out.

But in my experience, the much deeper work is what happens inside of us after we’ve said it.

Can I stay with myself when somebody’s disappointed?

Can I tolerate their reaction without taking responsibility for it?

Can I allow myself to feel scared or guilty without interpreting those feelings as proof that I’ve made a mistake?

Can I resist the urge to explain more, offer more, or reverse my decision just to make the discomfort go away?

That’s where so much of the transformation happens.

And the holidays give us plenty of opportunities to practice.

Because there are going to be people who don’t like the decisions we make.

There are going to be people who wish we’d do things differently.

There are going to be people who are disappointed.

And that doesn’t necessarily mean anything has gone wrong.

It means we’re separate people with separate preferences and needs.

And we get to have those.

We get to make decisions that work for us.

We get to protect our time, our energy, our money, and our peace.

And other people get to have their feelings about those decisions.

We don’t have to make those feelings go away for them. That’s their job.

And we don’t have to abandon ourselves because of them.

As we wrap up, I want to invite you to think about a time when someone was disappointed with a decision you made, and you stayed with yourself anyway.

Maybe it was something small.

Like you said no to an invitation.

Or maybe you didn’t answer a phone call when you weren’t available.

Maybe you told someone you couldn’t help them with something.

Or maybe it was a really big boundary that took everything you had to set.

Whatever it was, think about what helped you stay with your decision.

What did you do that helped you have your own back?

Did you take some time before responding?

Did you talk with someone supportive?

Did you remind yourself that you weren’t responsible for the other person’s feelings?

Did you calm your nervous system?

Did you simply allow yourself to be uncomfortable without doing anything to make the discomfort go away?

I want you to notice what worked.

Because those are the things you can draw on the next time you find yourself in a similar situation.

And if you can’t think of a time when you’ve done this yet, that’s okay too.

Think about an upcoming holiday situation where you might have an opportunity to practice.

What boundary might you want to set?

What reaction are you anticipating?

And what could you do to support yourself if that reaction happens?

Don’t forget to keep in mind why you’re settin that limit in the first place – is it to get more down time, spend less money, have more quality time with few people? Focus on what you want, not what you don’t want.

And remember, you don’t have to wait until you’re completely comfortable to set a boundary.

You can set it while you’re uncomfortable.

You can feel scared and still have your own back.

You can let somebody be disappointed and still stay connected to yourself.

And every time you do that, you’re teaching yourself something new.

You’re teaching yourself that you don’t have to abandon yourself to maintain connection with other people.

And that, my friends, is a completely different way of living.

Until next time, remember that you are worthy of love, dignity, and respect, especially from yourself.

Find this helpful? Share with a friend:

Posted in

Like what you've read and heard?

Try subscribing to my monthly newsletter, "Happy, Joyous and Free."
It will help you change your dysfunctional patterns of behavior.

Want to chat with me about your boundaries? Hop onto my calendar here for a free 30-minute Better Boundaries call.

* indicates required